Peabody's Billion-Dollar Coal Gamble Just Caught Fire

An underground fire throws Peabody's blockbuster Anglo American acquisition into chaos. Here's what's at stake.

Author's Avatar
Apr 09, 2025
Summary
  • Ignition event threatens Peabody’s $1B earnout and the future of a major steelmaking coal deal.
Article's Main Image

Peabody Energy (BTU, Financial) is hitting pause and reassessing its $3.775 billion deal to acquire Anglo American's steelmaking coal assets after a fire incident at the Moranbah North Mine last week. The mine is one of the crown jewels in the transaction, and any operational setback throws a wrench into what was supposed to be a clean handoff. Peabody says it's still in active talks with Anglo American and is keeping all legal options on the table. The original deal included a $2.05 billion upfront payment, $725 million in installments, and a $1 billion kicker tied to favorable conditions down the line.

This changes the math. The ignition event puts future production and valuation in question—especially the earnout portion that hinges on upside scenarios. For Peabody, the situation isn't just about risk—it's about timing, pricing, and whether the asset still fits their strategic puzzle. Investors looking at this deal as a long-term bet on steelmaking coal will want to watch how Peabody handles the fallout. Deals this size don't get restructured lightly—but neither are they rubber-stamped when new risks surface.

Anglo American, for its part, had pitched this divestment as a move toward a leaner, more focused business model. Now that clarity is murky. If the asset underperforms or gets delayed, Anglo's cash-upfront may still clear—but that $1 billion earnout? It's hanging in the balance. With global steel demand facing mixed signals and safety investigations underway, this deal just moved into a high-stakes phase. Expect volatility.

Disclosures

I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and have no plans to buy any new positions in the stocks mentioned within the next 72 hours. Click for the complete disclosure