Gazprom: Selling For Three Times Its Earnings

Author's Avatar
Sep 19, 2014
Article's Main Image

Company

Thanks to the Ukraine crisis and sanction put on Russia by the United States, has made Gazprom (GZPFY, Financial) (OGZPY, Financial) already undervalued more undervalued. Gazprom is the largest producer of natural gas in the world and provides 1/3 of the gas consumed by the Europen Union and only sells for 3x its earnings. The company is more profitable than any American oil company but has a lower market cap. Gazprom almost has ten times the natural gas reserves of ExxonMobil (XOM, Financial) but sell for 3x earnings while Exxon sells for 12.4x.

Company history

  • In 1989, the government transformed the Ministry of Gas Industry into Russia's first state-enterprise and called it State Gas Concern Gazprom. The government controlled the company by owning 100% of Gazprom stock.
  • In 1991, the Soviet Union dissolved and the assets of the former Soviet state in the gas sector were transfered to new created National Corporations.
  • In 1993, the government began to privative Gazprom. The company became a joint-stock company and started to distribute its shares under the voucher method. Every Russian citizen received vouchers to purchase share of the formly government owned enterprise.
  • By 1994, the 33% of the company was owned by 747,000 citizens who used the voucher from the Government to buy those share. 15% of the shares where given an purchased an allocated to the company's employees. The Russian government retained 40% of the remaining shares.
  • Over time the government gradually reduced its stake to 38%.
  • Gazprom slowly grew its credibilty with western capital markets and offered one percent of its equity to foreign investors in Global Depository Receipts. Had a sucessful bond offering of 2.5 billion as well.
  • When Vladimir Putin became president of Russia, he went on a campaign to rein in the oligards. He strength control of strategic companies that he saw as important to the nation of Russia.
  • Putin clearly view Gazprom as one of these companies, and went about to expand government control of the company.
  • The Government arranged multiple transactions with Gazprom subsidaries to aquire 10.73% of Gazprom stock costing the government $7 billion. After the purchase was completed and combined with the states already 38% stake gave the government majority control of the company.
  • After the government gain control over Gazprom, it removed the 20% restriction on foreign investors. This made the company fully open to foreign investors.
  • In 2007, Russia's government passed a federal law on gas grants, which gave Gazprom exclusive rights to export natural gas.
  • In May 2014, Gazprom and China's China National Petroleum Corporation made a 30 deal that is worth about $400 billion. According to the agreement Gazprom will deliver some 38 billion cubic meters of natual gas every year to eastern China. The first delivery is expected to start in 2018 four years from now.

Business overview

Gazprom is in the business of geological explogical exploration, production, transportation, storage, processing and marketing. The company is second behind Saudi Aramco in supplying energy to the world in 2013. Gazprom produced an average of 8.1 million barrels of oil equivalent per day in 2013, far above the 5.3 million barrels of oil equivalents produced per day by ExxonMobil. The company alone produces 20% of all the natural gas consumed by nearly every nation in Europe except for Belgium, The Netherlands, Switzerland and the United Kingdom. Gazprom has essentially a monoply in many of the European countries. The company's reserves a lone are large enough to make the company one of event the largest energy company in the world. Gazprom has proven gas reserves of 18.99 trillion cubic meters at the end of 2010 and this is 9.3 times greater than the natural gas reserves of ExxonMobil. Over the last decade the company's gas production has been stable, producing about 500 billion cubic meters of natural gas per year. Gazprom also annually produces 32 million tons of cubic oil and 12 million tons of gas condensate. The major parts of the Gazprom production fields are located in the Nadym-Pur-Tarz region in Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okug in Western Siberia.

Finances

03May20171357241493837844.jpg

Gazprom annual report

In 2013, Gazprom sales were approximately RUB $5.2 trillion and revenues were 3x that of ConocoPhilips (COP, Financial) even after the recent sharp decline in the Rouble. The company revenues in 2013 increased 10%. Revenues reflect Distribution Segment increase of 12% to RUB $2.963 Trillion. Gazprom Refining segment increased 12% to RUB $1.35 Trillion and Transportation segment increased 30% to RUB $163.27 billion. As well the company's Europe Natural Gas segment increased 17% to RUB $2.11 Trillion. The company had a net income of RUB $1.17 trillion or $32.9 billion that slightly higher than ExxonMobil's net income of $32.6 billion in 2013.

In the first quarter of 2014, Gazprom saw profits fall 41% from a year earlier mostly due to the events in the Ukraine. The company had to write-off 71.3 billion rubles or ($1.9) billion due to Ukraine's doubtful trade accounts. These write-offs were largely expected to happen. Ukraine's debt to Gazprom has risen to $5.4 billion and in June the company turned off its gas taps to Ukraine. Net profits for the first three months of the fell to $223 billion rubles and revenues were up 7% to $1.5 trillion rubles. Operating expensives climbed 15% to $1.09 trillion rubles.

Balance Sheet

2012 31/12 2011 31/12 2010 31/12 2009 31/12
Total Current Assets 2408746 2240293 1865895 1686974
Cash and Short Term Investments 436498 525335 448221 301896
Cash 475 533 261 4495
Cash & Equivalents 419061 500811 440525 245264
Short Term Investments 16962 23991 7435 52137
Total Receivables, Net 1335356 1087507 916290 986443
Accounts Receivables - Trade, Net 654324 537323 400252 393554
Total Inventory 459534 407530 325739 286719
Prepaid Expenses - - - -
Other Current Assets, Total 177358 219921 175645 111916
Total Assets 12068139 10900696 9235993 8368528
Property/Plant/Equipment, Total - Net 7818392 6718575 5486429 4899223
Property/Plant/Equipment, Total - Gross 11242010 9798007 8289333 7455797
Accumulated Depreciation, Total -3423618 -3079432 -2802904 -2556574
Goodwill, Net - - - -
Intangibles, Net - - - -
Long Term Investments 814888 897104 948574 901363
Note Receivable - Long Term 392388 415633 375277 500564
Other Long Term Assets, Total 633725 629091 559818 380404
Other Assets, Total - - - -
Total Current Liabilities 1489817 1309255 1011261 1047892
Accounts Payable 618117 533101 434568 318702
Payable/Accrued - - - -
Accrued Expenses 117357 95028 73105 73239
Notes Payable/Short Term Debt 70862 64926 63481 202937
Current Port. of LT Debt/Capital Leases 255945 301942 127571 233679
Other Current liabilities, Total 427536 314258 312536 219335
Total Liabilities 3676408 3437125 2986242 3042013
Total Long Term Debt 1177934 1173294 1124395 1189049
Long Term Debt 1177934 1173294 1124395 1189049
Capital Lease Obligations - - - -
Total Debt 1504741 1540162 1315447 1625665
Deferred Income Tax 429305 402728 333143 321524
Minority Interest 309363 297420 286610 322806
Other Liabilities, Total 269989 254428 230833 160742
Total Equity 8391731 7463571 6249751 5326515
Redeemable Preferred Stock, Total - - - -
Preferred Stock - Non Redeemable, Net - - - -
Common Stock, Total 325194 325194 325194 325194
Additional Paid-In Capital - - - -
Retained Earnings (Accumulated Deficit) 8170631 7242982 6028543 5105525
Treasury Stock - Common -104094 -104605 -103986 -104204
ESOP Debt Guarantee - - - -
Unrealized Gain (Loss) - - - -
Other Equity, Total - - - -
Total Liabilities & Shareholders' Equity 12068139 10900696 9235993 8368528
Total Common Shares Outstanding 22976 22947.51 22950.51 22949.51
Total Preferred Shares Outstanding - - - -

Income Statememt

2012 31/12 2011 31/12 2010 31/12 2009 31/12
Total Revenue 4764411 4637090 3597054 2991001
Revenue 4712022 4480852 3472627 2893800
Other Revenue, Total 52389 156238 124427 97201
Cost of Revenue, Total 1231118 1090828 790562 786464
Gross Profit 3480904 3390024 2682065 2107336
Total Operating Expenses 3475235 2980014 2482467 2134028
Selling/General/Admin. Expenses, Total 1689306 1415027 1245292 990455
Research & Development 19766 29489 24300 28524
Depreciation / Amortization 334162 275184 249693 221197
Interest Expense (Income) - Net Operating 22554 -6386 12876 -44223
Unusual Expense (Income) - -233 -765 -61
Other Operating Expenses, Total 178329 176105 160509 151672
Operating Income 1289176 1657076 1114587 856973
Interest Income (Expense), Net Non-Operating 222779 22860 81741 122462
Gain (Loss) on Sale of Assets - - 77375 -
Other, Net - - - -
Net Income Before Taxes 1511955 1679936 1273703 979435
Provision for Income Taxes 301389 337494 275710 185642
Net Income After Taxes 1210566 1342442 997993 793793
Minority Interest -27941 -35424 -29436 -14208
Equity In Affiliates - - - -
U.S GAAP Adjustment - - - -
Net Income Before Extraordinary Items 1182625 1307018 968557 779585
Total Extraordinary Items - - - -
Net Income 1182625 1307018 968557 779585
Total Adjustments to Net Income - - - -
Income Available to Common Excluding Extraordinary Items 1182625 1307018 968557 779585
Dilution Adjustment - - - -
Diluted Net Income 1182625 1307018 968557 779585
Diluted Weighted Average Shares 22900 22900 22900 23500
Diluted EPS Excluding Extraordinary Items 51.64 57.08 42.3 33.17
DPS - Common Stock Primary Issue - 8.97 3.85 2.39
Diluted Normalized EPS 51.95 57.19 40.06 33.17

Valuation

Currently the company is selling for 3x its earning, 0.35x book value, and selling for 2.2x its pretax earnings. Gazprom is clearly undervalued compared to the rest of the industry. The firm has more then 9x the natural gas reserves of ExxonMobil and the company's revenues were 3x that of ConocoPhilips. Exxon and ConocoPhilips both sell for higher multiples than Gazprom despite having more natural gas than Exxon and more revenues than ConocoPhilips. Exxon and ConocoPhilips sell for 12x to 10x their earnings while Gazpron sells for 3x. Clearly Gazprom should trade for at least 10x the firm's earnings, which means that the firm would sell for $26.90 per share. The firm should also sell for 10x its pretax earnings – that's $35.18 per share. Exxon and ConocoPhilips both sell for 2x to 1.7x, both companies' book value. Gazprom has a book valuue of $26.90 and only sells for 0.3x its book value and since the company has a return on assets of 8% should trade at book value. Based on the firm above average return on assets, the firm clearly should trade for at least book value or at a premium to book value. At book value Gazprom would sell at $26.90 or at 1.3x book value should trade at $34.97. Gazprom has a value range of $26 to $35 per share. and is clearly selling for 30 cent on the dollar. Offering any investor at least a 25% margin of safety on their investment.